Today's Most: Recent


Some Environmentalists Against Solar Power Posted by Andy Kondrat on September 25, 2008 at 11:17 am

We like solar power, right?  In the face of all this debate about coal and oil and gas and whatnot, we can look at solar power and find a solution, right?  Clean, renewable technology that any lover of the environment can get behind, right?

Wrong.

Some environmentalists have started to fight back against solar power, especially in the Southern California deserts, where many solar projects are planned.   The New York Times reports that there are concerns over endangered species, as well as the simple fact that, you know, some people live in the desert and don’t want it spoiled by solar panels everywhere.

But it is also home to the Mojave ground squirrel, the desert tortoise and the burrowing owl, and to human residents who describe themselves as desert survivors and who are unhappy about the proliferation of solar projects planned for their home turf.

‘We’re tired of everyone looking at the desert like a wasteland,’ said Donna Charpied, who lives with her husband, Larry, in Desert Center, Calif.

Some also complain that extensive solar power in the desert will take its toll on the water supply. Washing the panels takes away from the scant amounts of water in Southern California, and some of the panels use steam cleaners, which use even more water.   And then there are chemicals sprayed around the panels to inhibit brush growth, and the fact that some of these solar stations actually have fossil fuel-powered generators.

There’s a sort of NIMBY feeling about the opposition to the solar power, but I can at least see their side.   I mean, if I lived in the Coachella Valley near Joshua Tree, I probably moved there for the scenery, among other things.   I may not want thousands and thousands of acres of solar panels ruining my view.

Some environmentalists in the desert are calling for rooftop panels only to try and provide power.   And some are concerned that the government is against them.   The founder of one environmental group says, Our lawmakers have sold out to the big solar lobby.

Yup.   Big solar lobby.   So we don’t know how this is going to play out, but it very well may escalate.

Donna Charpied said desert residents of California and Nevada were planning some unspecified action within two months. The desert will not go quietly into that dark night, she said.

Kinda ominous.   takepart to learn the pros and cons of rooftop versus desert solar power and decide for yourself what you think.


CATEGORIES:  Environment


5
Discuss
Share
Act

Required information:



Add your comment:

Page 1 of 2 Next
Posted by lora on September 25, 2008 at 1:40 pm

And of course we should listen to them. We cannot be greedy with our power needs and kill anything in the process of building it. The planet as a single cell needs to be considered.

Replies (0)
Posted by jack on September 26, 2008 at 5:40 pm

I think those solar panels look quite spectacular in the deserts…

Replies (0)
Posted by Dave on September 28, 2008 at 2:49 pm

I think we should take both views about solar power into account, and come to some sort of compromise. Like building solar power towers. It would look ugly (to some people, I think it would look amazing), but it wouldnt have such an effect on the envoironment.

Dave, 14

Replies (0)
Page 1 of 2 Next
Page 2 of 2 Prev
Posted by Vern M. on January 26, 2009 at 4:59 pm

Correct me if I’m wrong, but almost all of the acreage in most Western states is Federal land isn’t it? If someone wanted to install a massive array of solar power panels, wouldn’t they need to either get permission from the government, or buy the land from them? Since rooftop panels are what you might call a foregone conclusion in Southern Cali, it seems to me that the contractors who intend to install these projects and the government who administers the land should be the only targets for any upset residents.

Also, personally I agree that Solar Panels aren’t eyesores… They look rather high tech and purposeful to me.

Replies (0)
Posted by MM on February 6, 2009 at 7:05 pm

we really should be taking both sides into consideration, I mean, like there’s other land to be used in the US for “solar stations”. Although they might look pretty, we cant let them get away with killing plants and harming animals in the process of trying to get the US, and really the world, to start going green–how ironic (and not in a funny way), they’re using fossil fuels to make a clean source of energy that is trying to stop the use of fossil fuels………….really, we need a better solution…..

Replies (0)
Page 2 of 2 Prev
Current Actions:

TakePart Cartoons:

  • Cartoon 1
  • Cartoon 2
  • Cartoon 4
  • Cartoon 5
  • Cartoon 3

Stay Informed with TakePart:

Get Blog Updates:

Archives By Month: